The Bull Elephant
  • Home
  • About The Bull Elephant
  • Fun Stuff
  • Contact The Bull Elephant
Latest Posts
The Censure of Senator Amanda Chase
Right From The Start: A Strange New World
Pete Snyder kicks off his campaign for Governor...
SCC members supporting a primary attempt to back...
We Finally Made It
No new Virginia House districts in 2021
Biden ‘stimulus’ will increase national debt, shorten recovery,...

The Bull Elephant

  • Home
  • About The Bull Elephant
  • Fun Stuff
  • Contact The Bull Elephant

Donald Trump’s Tax Plan

written by Guest Contributor Fred Morrison October 4, 2015

Let me start my remarks by saying I’m neither for nor against Donald Trump.

When Mr. Trump says he will have a zero income tax rate for the lowest earning individuals and couples, I mildly disagree with that notion.

Why, you ask?

For two reasons.

First, there is a disincentive to work if you’re $1 below that threshold because the moment you exceed it, your take-home pay is going to be dramatically lower.

Second, unless everyone has “skin in the game,” even if only a comparatively tiny amount, there are fewer people to keep the politicians from raising the rates.

What would I do differently? First, take the rates down from four different ones to a single one with a simple formula:

Take everything you earn, no matter how you earn it (wages, salary, dividends, interest, capital gains, gambling – in other words, however you wish), subtract $50,000 from it. If the result is zero or negative, you pay nothing.  If result is positive, pay 10% of that.So, if you make $50,000 or below, you pay $0 in income taxes.

If you work hard and make an additional $5,000 the following year, making your earnings $55,000, you pay $500, calculated as: ($55,000 – $50,000) * 10% = $500  That makes your *EFFECTIVE* tax rate a mere 1%. A person making $1,000,000 would pay $95,000 in taxes, calculated as: ($1,000,000 – $55,000) * 10% = $95,000. That works out to an *EFFECTIVE* rate of 9.5%

Both the person making $55,000 and the millionaire have “skin in the game” *NO MATTER HOW SMALL* and will keep a watchful eye on any politician who dares to raise the rate from 10% to, say for example, 15%.

The person making $55,000 isn’t “punished” for getting a raise that takes him over the threshold like Mr. Trump’s plan does.

What’s the catch in my plan, you ask?

Several, as it turns out.

No more deductions. *FOR ANYTHING*. No more credits that allow people to get back more than they paid in (“earned income credit”, “child credit”, etc.). You decide how many kids you want based on what you think you can afford. You decide how big a home to buy, based on what you can afford, not what the government thinks you can afford. The government stays the hell out of that (and any other) decision.

No more “picking winners and losers with the tax code,” or worse, crony capitalism like Solyndra and Ener1 (versus true, free-market capitalism).

An interesting side note to my example: it seems to stand the notion of “The 1%” on its head with people at the bottom considered “The 1%” (effective tax rate).

Donald Trump’s Tax Plan was last modified: October 4th, 2015 by Guest Contributor Fred Morrison
Crony CapitalismDonald Trump tax plan
3 comments
Guest Contributor Fred Morrison

Fred's an aging baby boomer, son of a World War II combat veteran of thePacific theater, who grew up in Phoenix, Arizona, graduated from PhoenixCollege and Arizona State University, married my wife of now 37 years inMinnesota and moved to the Virginia suburbs of Washington DC back in 1988, ironically within just a few days after Rush Limbaugh first took the air waves nationwide. When I'm not writing computer programs for a living, I volunteer as part of Microsoft TEALS at the local high school, helping the classroom teacher brain-wash (they think I'm actually helping them) the next generation of computer programmers with the same great(?) habits I developed over the past 40+ years. Lastly, I serve as a Virginia Election officer at my local precinct during every election. Since I stopped playing ice hockey, I actually have some free time now.

Your life will be better if you click one of these

The Censure of Senator Amanda Chase

January 27, 2021

Right From The Start: A Strange New...

January 27, 2021

Pete Snyder kicks off his campaign for...

January 26, 2021

SCC members supporting a primary attempt to...

January 26, 2021

We Finally Made It

January 26, 2021

No new Virginia House districts in 2021

January 26, 2021

Biden ‘stimulus’ will increase national debt, shorten...

January 26, 2021

Northam administration cuts off hospitals’ supply of...

January 25, 2021

How to Take a Flawed Healthcare System...

January 25, 2021

The curious nature of conventional wisdom

January 24, 2021

Fun Stuff

  • Sunday Memes–Bernie’s mittens edition

  • We’re on the eve of Socialism

  • This week’s memes, Buffalo Man edition

  • This week in Memes–Happy New Year edition

  • Sunday Memes–Stimulus edition

Advertisement

Advertisement

Sign Up for Email Alerts

Select list(s):

Advertisement

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

@2017 Bull Elephant Media LLC.


Back To Top