The Bull Elephant
  • Home
  • About The Bull Elephant
  • Fun Stuff
  • Contact The Bull Elephant
Latest Posts
Northam to relax some COVID restrictions
Liberty University denies any agreement reached with RPV...
That Never Happened
Coca-Cola reportedly told its staff to ‘be less...
General Assembly passes bill to ban the death...
Graphs: Twitter, Facebook Followers For All Virginia 2021...
Sunday Funday Memes!

The Bull Elephant

  • Home
  • About The Bull Elephant
  • Fun Stuff
  • Contact The Bull Elephant

FTC goes ‘Star Chamber’ on warrant transparency

written by Guest Contributor Mark Fitzgibbons November 29, 2015

Intrepid reporter Kathryn Watson at The Daily Caller News Foundation just wanted to get copies of administrative subpoenas issued by the Federal Trade Commission. The FTC replied to her Freedom of Information Act request with obstruction.

Nobody knows how many administrative subpoenas are issued by government agencies. Administrative subpoenas are warrants for records such as private “papers” and emails. They are issued unilaterally by government bureaucrats, and are impossible to reconcile with the Fourth Amendment’s requirements of “oath and affirmation” of “probable cause” before neutral judges.

Watson and The Daily Caller News Foundation have been doing the work that Congress has failed to do in its oversight functions, and have issued multiple FOIA requests to various government agencies to get a sense of how many of these subpoenas are issued.

Watson recently wrote about the FTC’s response to her FOIA request. The FTC, under President Obama’s mockable “most transparent” administration in American history, “claims in a Nov. 24 letter that at least some of those records are exempt ‘because disclosure of that material could reasonably be expected to interfere with the conduct of the commission’s law enforcement activities.’”

The FTC’s letter to Watson expressing refusal to obey FOIA corruptly relies on a 1978 case, NLRB v. Robbins Tire and Rubber Co., which held that FOIA exempts statements of witnesses who would testify in disputes between labor organizations and businesses. The basis for this exemption is fear that disclosure of witnesses would lead to their being intimidated against testifying.

It is hard to believe that any witness statements would be found in administrative subpoenas. Even if they were, they could be redacted. Reporting by the press, it appears, is really what the FTC believes as interfering with their law enforcement activities.

As I’ve written, administrative subpoenas are relics of the Star Chamber, the notoriously secretive and abusive King’s council that the English despised and eventually outlawed in 1641. And, unilaterally issued warrants were considered unlawful even before the Fourth Amendment was written.

Administrative subpoenas are frequently used as bureaucratic weapons to punish or intimidate businesses and others. As reported at National Law Journal, one company “put out of business under the weight of a Federal Trade Commission data-privacy investigation is now suing three agency attorneys for allegedly bringing a case based on ‘fictional’ evidence.”

The FTC has gone full “Star Chamber” in its secrecy and use of administrative subpoenas. It’s time for Congress to act and stop this soft police state among federal agencies. Bureaucrats need to comply with the Fourth Amendment. Warrants require probable cause and oath and affirmation before neutral judges.

Originally Published at The American Thinker
FTC goes ‘Star Chamber’ on warrant transparency was last modified: November 29th, 2015 by Guest Contributor Mark Fitzgibbons
administrative subpoenaDaily CallerFourth AmendmentFTCKathryn WatsonStar Chamber
2 comments
Guest Contributor Mark Fitzgibbons

Mark J. Fitzgibbons is a constitutional lawyer and co-author with Richard A. Viguerie of The Law That Governs Government: Reclaiming The Constitution From Usurpers And Society's Biggest Lawbreaker.

Your life will be better if you click one of these

Northam to relax some COVID restrictions

February 24, 2021

Liberty University denies any agreement reached with...

February 24, 2021

That Never Happened

February 24, 2021

SCC backs drive-in convention in Lynchburg

February 23, 2021

Coca-Cola reportedly told its staff to ‘be...

February 23, 2021

General Assembly passes bill to ban the...

February 22, 2021

Graphs: Twitter, Facebook Followers For All Virginia...

February 21, 2021

Sunday Funday Memes!

February 21, 2021

The RPV at the Leadership Crossroads

February 20, 2021

Results of Amanda Chase lawsuit against RPV...

February 20, 2021

Fun Stuff

  • Sunday Funday Memes!

  • Sunday Memes–We deserve a laugh today

  • Best Super Bowl commercials 2021

  • Sunday Memes, Circleback!

  • Senator John Kennedy’s Witty Humor

Advertisement

Advertisement

Sign Up for Email Alerts

[wysija_form id="5"]

Advertisement

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

@2017 Bull Elephant Media LLC.


Back To Top