The Bull Elephant
  • Home
  • About The Bull Elephant
  • Fun Stuff
  • Contact The Bull Elephant
Latest Posts
Republican House ‘leadership’ just isn’t
Biden nominee’s racist claims about whites weren’t satirical
Are face masks beneficial or dangerous?
Republican Party Plan should allow delegates with religious...
A law to reduce voter integrity
Warnings of Danger – Then and Now
It’s Sunday! Time for Memes!

The Bull Elephant

  • Home
  • About The Bull Elephant
  • Fun Stuff
  • Contact The Bull Elephant

McDonnell Guilty, Which Va. Politician to be Charged Next?

written by Paul A. Prados September 5, 2014

Former Governor McDonnell is the first Virginia Governor to be convicted for crimes committed while in office.  The defense went horribly awry, some legal rulings went against the McDonnells, and all Virginia politicians are subject to potential prosecution.[read_more]

What went wrong?Bob McDonnell

Let us start with the obvious:  There was a major loss on the issue of jury instructions that is not the fault of the defense and provides a strong basis for appeal.

Boiled down to a simple level though this is a criminal case, with the highest burden of proof available in the United States: Guilt must be proven beyond a reasonable doubt.

Going into the trial the defense focused on the prospect of putting dozens of character witnesses on the stand.  The defense indicated that Bob McDonnell’s character would be a “centerpiece of his defense.”  A few character witnesses might be helpful, but how would this establish reasonable doubt?

Then, during the course of the trial, the defense appeared to be focused on the status of the marriage between Maureen and Bob McDonnell.  The theory behind this is that Bob McDonnell supposedly had limited communications with Jonnie Williams.  If that is the case, then in order for Bob McDonnell to misuse his office he would have had to engage in a conspiracy with his wife to misuse public office.  That conspiracy would be hard to prove if the couple barely spoke and did not get along.  Although this could be used to completely disprove a major element of the prosecution’s case, the focus is not on poking holes in the prosecution’s narrative to establish reasonable doubt.

Closing argument is the opportunity to tell a coherent story to the jury, and argue the legal standard.  The defense appeared so focused on telling their own alternative story, they did not emphasize the basic premise of every criminal defense, i.e. the prosecution did not prove their case beyond a reasonable doubt.  Was there reasonable doubt that McDonnell knew Jonnie Williams expected favors in return for the gifts, probably.

The defense was focused so heavily on affirmatively proving innocence, they minimized the fundamental importance of simply establishing reasonable doubt.

McDonnell rejected a plea deal early on.  There had to be more discussions.  Did McDonnell and his counsel err in refusing a reasonable deal leading into trial, or was the prosecution intransigent?

So what happens next?

Not an appeal.  Next comes sentencing, and not for four months.  Only after a final order is entered can an appeal even occur.  This means the case will not reach the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals until spring 2015 and oral argument and rulings probably will not occur until fall 2015.

Based on my understanding of the broad reading of the criminal statutes in the jury instructions the McDonnells have a plausible basis for having the convictions for public services fraud overturned.

Maureen McDonnell, even with a favorable appeal, is highly unlikely to have the obstruction of justice charges overturned.  There are no reports of claims that the jury instructions for the obstruction charge were improper.

I have heard that one grounds for appeal is Judge Spencer’s denial of the McDonnells’ request to be tried separately.  This is likely a decision given to the sound discretion of the trial judges and unlikely to be successful grounds for appeal.

What this means for Virginia politicians

Receive a gift + meet with the donor/gift-giver, because that is what normal politicians do + possibly assist them in some minor way in your official capacity = go to jail.  Essentially the simple fact that a gift giver has given something to a politician allows the inference that there is an informal arrangement to help the giver on some future date.

In an early scene in the Godfather Don Corleone agrees to do a favor for one of his guests and states “Some day, and that day may never come, I will call upon you to do a service for me. …  until that day accept this . . . as a gift . . .”  These words were never spoken between Gov. McDonnell and Johnnie Williams.  The jury inferred these words from their behaviors.  EVERY GIFT going forward to any office holder (even outside Virginia) will be regarded under federal law as a quid pro quo from Don Corleone.

To that end I agree with Chris Saxman.

McDonnell Guilty, Which Va. Politician to be Charged Next? was last modified: September 5th, 2014 by Paul A. Prados
Governor Bob McDonnellGovernor Bob McDonnell Defense
4 comments
Paul A. Prados

Having fallen prey to the allure of DC politics in college, Paul escaped only to make the similar judgment error of going to law school. Trained at the side of a sitting state Senator, Paul is now the owner of a law firm in Reston, Virginia. In previous years Paul built a base of support on Twitter @ppradoslaw and founded and wrote for a blog on Virginia politics and legal procedure northernvirginialawyer.blogspot.com. As a pro-life libertarian, Paul finds himself at home within the broader conservative movement, and believes in a big tent Republican Party. In May 2016 Paul was elected as Chairman of the 11th Congressional District Republican Committee. Paul resides in western Fairfax County with his wife and children.

Your life will be better if you click one of these

Republican House ‘leadership’ just isn’t

April 21, 2021

Biden nominee’s racist claims about whites weren’t...

April 20, 2021

Are face masks beneficial or dangerous?

April 20, 2021

Republican Party Plan should allow delegates with...

April 19, 2021

A law to reduce voter integrity

April 18, 2021

Warnings of Danger – Then and Now

April 18, 2021

It’s Sunday! Time for Memes!

April 18, 2021

Record breaking fundraising in the Governor’s race

April 17, 2021

School-Discipline Statistics Straight out of an Opium...

April 17, 2021

Statewide candidates money on hand

April 16, 2021

Fun Stuff

  • It’s Sunday! Time for Memes!

  • Sunday Funday Memes!

  • Memes! Memes! Memes!

  • Sunday–Funday Memes

  • Sunday Memes–the bullied Royals Edition

Advertisement

Advertisement

Sign Up for Email Alerts

[wysija_form id="5"]

Advertisement

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

@2017 Bull Elephant Media LLC.


Back To Top