The Bull Elephant
  • Home
  • About The Bull Elephant
  • Fun Stuff
  • Contact The Bull Elephant
Latest Posts
Republican Roadmap to Victory in Virginia
News from The Advance
Culpeper County sheriff to deputize thousands if Red...
The America hating left
How the GOP can win the next election
Get ready for the RPV ‘Dirge’
The Consequences of Failure

The Bull Elephant

  • Home
  • About The Bull Elephant
  • Fun Stuff
  • Contact The Bull Elephant
Democrat candidates for president, Senators Elizabeth Warren, Bernie Sanders and Kristin Gillibrand (Photo credit: PBS (of course) )

Medicare for All – My Own Experience

written by Guest Contributor James Poplar May 20, 2019

As we approach another election cycle, many Democratic candidates advocate “Medicare for All” (e.g. universal Healthcare), sometimes stated as “Free Healthcare for All.”  As an active duty member of the United States military, I participated in – or, rather, was subjected to – “free government healthcare” for over thirty years, and I would like to share some of my observations with your readers.

I believe that in the most prosperous nation on Earth, our goal should for the private sector to provide quality affordable healthcare to all, under sensible and practical governmental regulation.  Many believe that cradle-to-grave healthcare is a “right” guaranteed by the Bill Of Rights or the U.S. Constitution.  For Progressives and others to say that unlimited healthcare is a legally-established right for every American is a gross misunderstanding of the Founding Fathers’ concepts of rights.  Healthcare – like schooling, housing and gainful employment – are certainly NEEDS, but do not rise to the level of constitutional RIGHTS. (Neither do certain proposed reproductive “rights” but that is a subject for another day).

While I was on active military duty, healthcare for both me and my family was indeed “free of charge,” but often required waiting for months before an outpatient appointment came available.  The quality of care varied wildly, from excellence to gross negligence, but mostly fell in-between. Inpatient care (once you could get in the system) was usually better than outpatient care, because as an outpatient you almost never saw the same doctors twice in a row, which produced a system in which doctors treating patients with chronic or recurring problems had to start from scratch with each follow-up visit.   My personal experience was that the providers’/doctors’ expertise varied greatly from visit to visit.

My first wife’s outpatient experience with “Medicare for All,” casts a harsh light upon the dangers and unintended consequences of universal healthcare.  

To begin with, once “free” care is provided by the government, approved access to other – private, and paid – providers will be tightly restricted, and healthy competition will be sharply curtailed. As a military spouse, my wife endured multiple sacrifices (over twenty moves and numerous family separations 6-9  months), and it required great courage and persistence to raise a family, mentor many younger wives and help them cope with the challenges of being a military spouse.

During one deployment, she experienced chest pain and was seen by a seemingly random series of outpatient physicians and medical personnel – never seeing the same healthcare professional twice.  Each clinic visit included a chest x-ray and ended with the same diagnosis: “There’s nothing wrong with you, take an aspirin and rest.”  

After going through this drill for over a year, her pain level was such that she literally could not move. One night, Emergency Room personnel admitted her as an inpatient.  Yet another chest x-ray confirmed stage-4 cancer that had metastasized throughout her body. After many months of outright medical indifference and neglect, she was now given less than a year to live.  

Her attending physician noted that her previous x-rays had, in fact, shown a tumor was present, but that the government-employed healthcare “professionals” who examined her during numerous “free” outpatient visits had simply “overlooked” every opportunity there had been to save or prolong her life. Tragically, this was the price she had to pay under what is now termed “Medicare For All.”

I submit these experiences not for sympathy, but as a warning that a government-run universal health care system, by its very nature, will sever the lifeline that medical professionals call “continuum of care.”  A lack of competition among healthcare providers, and patients’ inability to choose their providers/doctors, are only part of the true cost of “free” government healthcare. And in fact, Universal Healthcare systems in other nations around the globe are NOT actually free of charge.  In these countries, the basic plans cover prescription drugs, dental and vision, but access to hospital care typically requires payment of a “premium tax” on a sliding scale.

Everyone knows that healthcare reform is needed to reduce costs and improve care. But I urge Virginians to consider the consequences of rushing to adopt this election year’s hot political fad by simply throwing out the many viable healthcare options currently in place, including Medicare, Tricare, Veterans Administration, Medicaid, the Affordable Care Act and private insurance.

Let’s not throw the proverbial baby out with the bathwater.


Medicare for All – My Own Experience was last modified: May 20th, 2019 by Guest Contributor James Poplar
Free health careMedicare for all
0 comment
Guest Contributor James Poplar

James R Poplar III, of Quicksburg, served in the Government of the United States of America for over forty years. He is a retired Navy “Commodore” having three at sea Commands – two ships and an Amphibious Squadron. At Vanderbilt and National Defense University he taught national security affairs. He is an active member of the Shenandoah County Republican Committee.

Your life will be better if you click one of these

Republican Roadmap to Victory in Virginia

December 8, 2019

News from The Advance

December 7, 2019

Culpeper County sheriff to deputize thousands if...

December 7, 2019

The America hating left

December 7, 2019

How the GOP can win the next...

December 5, 2019

Get ready for the RPV ‘Dirge’

December 4, 2019

The Consequences of Failure

December 4, 2019

Shaun Kenney returning to RPV

December 3, 2019

Make the 6th District Republican Party Great...

December 3, 2019

Retirement Lies and Statistics

December 3, 2019

Fun Stuff

  • Holiday TV viewing schedule

  • Snow forecast Virginia winter 2019-2020

  • Reliving History with the Chicago Cubs

  • Innocents Abroad (II)

  • College destinations for TJHSST class of 2019

Advertisement

Advertisement

Sign Up for Email Alerts

Select list(s):

Advertisement

Recent Comments

  • News from The Advance – The Bull Elephant on Shaun Kenney returning to RPV
  • Peter Strzok and Lisa Page and their spouses–photos – The … – Bugaluu on Peter Strzok and Lisa Page and their spouses–photos
  • Get ready for the RPV ‘Dirge’ – The Bull Elephant on 8 ideas to grow the GOP in Virginia
  • The Consequences of Failure – The Bull Elephant on A Conservative BHAG
  • The Consequences of Failure – The Bull Elephant on The Republicans Empty Wagon

Advertisement

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

@2017 Bull Elephant Media LLC.


Back To Top