The Bull Elephant
  • Home
  • About The Bull Elephant
  • Fun Stuff
  • Contact The Bull Elephant
Latest Posts
Remembering Fallujah, Memorial Day 2025
Wisconsin Judge’s Dubious Claim of Judicial Immunity From...
Memorial Day Poppies
The Woke Episcopal Church Tells Trump that They...
Sunday Memes–Sea shells down by the sea shore
Genocide in Gaza?
Former FBI Directer James Comey threatens Trump

The Bull Elephant

  • Home
  • About The Bull Elephant
  • Fun Stuff
  • Contact The Bull Elephant

Grassroots undermined just before the Advance

written by Paul A. Prados December 14, 2016

On Friday December 9, 2016 the Virginia Republican State Central Committee struck a heavy blow against the grassroots by gutting its own authority in favor of a seven person committee.

As the election of officers (June meeting) and the choice between primary v. convention (August meeting) were behind us, and the December Republican Bacchanalia was ahead of us, not very many people were paying attention.

One of the few items on the docket was an appeal I filed to a general counsel ruling from August.

The Party Plan

The Republican Party of Virginia Party Plan governs how party officials are elected, how they are removed from the party, and our rights and obligations.  It is the founding document of the Republican Party of Virginia.  It is well intentioned, but flawed.

The Party Plan can only be changed by a statewide convention body (this is rarely if ever done) or by a 3/4 vote of the State Central Committee.

Ambiguities in the U.S. Constitution are interpreted by our court system.  Ambiguities in our state Party Plan are interpreted via an odd system.

Certain party officials or groups of party officials are allowed to request rulings of the General Counsel on interpretations of the Party Plan.  The General Counsel, a single human being, (appointed by the RPV Chairman, and approved by the SCC) then issues a binding opinion.  In order to prevent a GC Opinion from running roughshod over the party plan there is an appeals process.

This appeals process has been manipulated.

The appeals process

The party plan says that any appeal of a GC Opinion can be made to either the SCC or to a seven member appeals committee.  The Party Plan does not specify that the person appealing can choose where it goes, but that is how RPV currently interprets it.

If appealed to the SCC, the SCC takes a final vote and accepts, rejects, or modifies the GC Opinion.  This result then becomes the final say on interpretation of the Party Plan.

If appealed to the Appeals Committee and the Appeals Committee upholds the GC Opinion, the Party Plan says that the GC Opinion may then be appealed to the full SCC.

*BUT*

If appealed to the Appeals Committee, and the Appeals Committee overturns the GC Opinion this is what the party plan says about the right to appeal:

“……………………………………………………..[crickets]……………………………………………………….”

If appealed to the Appeals Committee, and the Appeals Committee overturns even the tiniest portion of the GC Opinion this is what the party plan says about the right to appeal:

“……………………………………………………..[crickets]……………………………………………………….”

The Party Plan is silent about what is and is not allowed in those instances.

I was told by staff that there is no right to appeal from a negative Appeals Committee ruling, so I requested a GC Opinion about this issue.

The GC (who I am not criticizing) issued a GC Opinion that says that this:

“……………………………………………………..[crickets]……………………………………………………….”

= there is no right to appeal and the Appeals Committee ruling is final.

The SCC’s unquestionable power

Article X § C of the Party Plan grants the SCC final say on all timely appeals of GC Opinions:

xc

Article X § C exists to preserve the sovereignty of the SCC as the final decision maker on all disputes, in part, because your representatives that you voted on at District Conventions make up the vast majority of members of SCC.

So I appealed the GC Opinion…

SCC votes against itself

The SCC voted 32-41 to reject my appeal.  The main two arguments against the appeal were:

  • If we support this appeal we are acting like Democrats who ask activist judges to rewrite the Constitution. This argument was made by a member of SCC who cynically used the Appeals Committee to accomplish overturning a GC Opinion just a few months ago and did not want it brought before the SCC.

 

  • Upholding my appeal runs counter to the plain language of the Party Plan. This was communicated to me privately. As laid out above, the Party Plan is silent in Article X § A, and is unquestionable as to the supreme authority granted to SCC in Art. X § C.  There is no plain language of the Party Plan I was asking to be overturned.

The Appeals Committee

The Appeals Committee is designated under the party plan, and not appointed by the Chairman. It is made up of:

The RPV Party Chairman (Elected by the grassroots at our quadrennial state convention)

The First Vice Chairman of RPV  (Elected by the SCC every four years)

The Eastern Vice Chairwoman (Elected by the SCC every four years)

The Eastern Vice Chairman (Elected by the SCC every four years)

The Western Vice Chairwoman (Elected by the SCC every four years)

The Western Vice Chairman (Elected by the SCC every four years)

Representative of the Joint Republican Legislative Caucus (Appointed by Republican officeholders)

Recent determinations of the Appeals Committee have been openly published.

The end result is that if someone has friends making up a four member majority on the appeals committee and they want to manipulate the Party Plan they can request a GC Opinion, appeal it to their friends, and interpret the Party Plan in their favor with a four member vote made up almost entirely of people not selected by the grassroots.

 

I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again.  It is almost as if those in power do not realize that some day they will not be in power and the instruments of power will be turned back upon them.

A few final notes

I believe that only a few members actually intended their vote against the appeal in a nefarious manner, most did not realize how dangerous this is.

The 11th Congressional District elected four new members in May.  We are the only evenly split delegation between the two “factions” on RPV.  As is similar in the past, I am proud to have stood shoulder to shoulder with each of my District representatives on this vote.

There was no roll call vote, as I literally forgot to request it.

There is a Committee appointed to review and make recommendations to the appeals process.  Although appointed in August, as of the Advance they had not yet met.  There are a mix of representatives and nearly all Congressional Districts have an appointee.  The 11th Congressional District does not have representation on this Committee.

Grassroots undermined just before the Advance was last modified: December 14th, 2016 by Paul A. Prados

Like this:

Like Loading...
Party planRPVscc
0 comment
Paul A. Prados

Having fallen prey to the allure of DC politics in college, Paul escaped only to make the similar judgment error of going to law school. Trained at the side of a sitting state Senator, Paul is now the owner of a law firm in Reston, Virginia. In previous years Paul built a base of support on Twitter @ppradoslaw and founded and wrote for a blog on Virginia politics and legal procedure northernvirginialawyer.blogspot.com. As a pro-life libertarian, Paul finds himself at home within the broader conservative movement, and believes in a big tent Republican Party. In May 2016 Paul was elected as Chairman of the 11th Congressional District Republican Committee. Paul resides in western Fairfax County with his wife and children.

Your life will be better if you click one of these

Remembering Fallujah, Memorial Day 2025

May 23, 2025

Wisconsin Judge’s Dubious Claim of Judicial Immunity...

May 21, 2025

Memorial Day Poppies

May 21, 2025

The Woke Episcopal Church Tells Trump that...

May 20, 2025

Sunday Memes–Sea shells down by the sea...

May 18, 2025

Genocide in Gaza?

May 16, 2025

Former FBI Directer James Comey threatens Trump

May 15, 2025

Bombs Away!

May 15, 2025

Meme of the Day

May 14, 2025

The Democrats and neocons don’t understand the...

May 14, 2025

Leave a Comment

Fun Stuff

  • Sunday Memes–Sea shells down by the sea shore

  • Meme of the Day

  • Meme of the Day

  • Sunday Memes–Make Alcatraz Great Again

  • Meme(s) of the day

Advertisement

Advertisement

Sign Up for Email Alerts


Select list(s):

Check your inbox or spam folder now to confirm your subscription.

Advertisement

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

@2017 Bull Elephant Media LLC.


Back To Top
 

Loading Comments...
 

    %d