The Bull Elephant
  • Home
  • About The Bull Elephant
  • Fun Stuff
  • Contact The Bull Elephant
Latest Posts
Sunday Memes–Shame on Gavin Newsome and Pam Bondi
The Foundation of Democracy
Memes of the Day
The Case for Insurrection
So what is the end state in Ukraine?
Gov. Youngkin’s wife and family members rescued from...
E Pluribus Unum– a reflection of who Republicans...

The Bull Elephant

  • Home
  • About The Bull Elephant
  • Fun Stuff
  • Contact The Bull Elephant

Showdown Over the Incumbent Protection Act in 2015!

written by Paul A. Prados December 4, 2014

In 2015, we may finally see the death of the Incumbent Protection Act, a law long supported by opponents of nominating conventions.

History

The law, Virginia Code § 24.2-509, allows the incumbent members of the General Assembly who won their party’s nomination via a state-run open primary may choose for themselves the method of their renomination, without regard to the wishes of the relevant political party committee.  This includes forcing a selection of a state-run open primary in which, for example, Democrats may participate in the selection of the Republican Party’s nominees.

In 2007, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit handed down its ruling in Miller v. Brown declaring Virginia’s open primary statute invalid in matters in which incumbents choose a method of party nomination contrary to the desires of the local party committee.  This decision, left unappealed by the Virginia State Board of Elections, contains the following analysis of the Incumbent Protection Act:

The [Supreme] Court stressed that the freedom to associate for the common advancement of political beliefs necessarily presupposes the freedom to identify the people who constitute the association, and to limit the association to those people only.  (Internal quotations and citations omitted)

In other words, parties have a right to choose who participates in the nominating process.

[A]t least for purposes of selecting a nomination method, Virginia does not view the incumbent legislator as a representative of the party.

…the [State Board of Election]’s contention that the Committee may use various means to compel Senator Martin to accede to its wishes regarding the method of nomination appears contrary to [the Incumbent Protection Act.]

The Incumbent Protection Act is odious as it allows the incumbent to interfere with party decision making and possibly allow outsiders into the nomination process against the will of the party.

Even though Miller v. Brown contained such substantially unfavorable language to the Incumbent Protection Act, no one has challenged it in SEVEN intervening years.

Until now.

The 2015 method of nomination in the 24th

On December 3, 2014 the members of the Republican Party’s 24th Senate Legislative District Committee, after consulting with counsel, voted 6-1 to hold a convention as the nomination method in the District.

In deciding on this course of action, Ken Adams, the Chairman for the District Committee said

Our goal is to overturn an unconstitutional and unjust law and in doing so, profoundly change the political landscape in Virginia…[If successful,] incumbents will be required to come back to the grassroots to be renominated.

After Speaking with Chairman Adams I can say the District Committee is well aware of the gravity of its actions and is committed to getting to the final resolution.  This is about restoring power to local committees to hold Republican standard bearers accountable to the grassroots.

There are arguably three people running for the nomination:

Senator Emmett Hanger (who claims he will decide after the General Assembly session)

Marshall Pattie (A former Democrat doing much to atone)

Dan Moxley (long rumored/just announced)

But what if Sen. Hanger selects a convention as well?

The legal fight will be called off.

But, the District Committee has to file their decision of nomination method between 125 and 105 days before the scheduled primary.  If Sen. Hanger selects a primary, and if, as they did in Miller v. Brown, the State Board of Elections ignores the decision of the political party and instead proceeds with a primary, the stage will be set for a fight by approximately 104 days before the potential scheduled primary.  However, I am sure an enterprising lawyer can figure out how to use Miller v. Brown’s earlier precedent to get into court before then, when the threat of conflict is realistic.

The stakes for Senator Hanger are high

The incumbent is almost always heavily favored.  In a three way race, the possibility of a challenger can diminish to nothing in an open primary.  In a convention, organization and loyalty will often trump incumbency, and more importantly, the bar is usually set at 50%, meaning that if no single candidate gets a majority on the first ballot the candidate with the lowest percentage of the vote is dropped before the next ballot is voted.  If Sen. Hanger is running, expect him to spend a hefty bit on legal fees in order to try to avoid a convention.  We expect that the respective GOP caucuses of both houses, along with an army of lawyers recruited by pro-primary consultants and lobbyists, to come to his aid.

I, for one, am thankful that the 24th district LDC has shown the backbone to take on the Incumbent Protection Act, and help the Republican party throughout Virginia.

Showdown Over the Incumbent Protection Act in 2015! was last modified: September 10th, 2015 by Paul A. Prados

Like this:

Like Loading...
#VA24Dan MoxleyEmmett Hangerincumbent protection actMarshall Pattie
0 comment
Paul A. Prados

Having fallen prey to the allure of DC politics in college, Paul escaped only to make the similar judgment error of going to law school. Trained at the side of a sitting state Senator, Paul is now the owner of a law firm in Reston, Virginia. In previous years Paul built a base of support on Twitter @ppradoslaw and founded and wrote for a blog on Virginia politics and legal procedure northernvirginialawyer.blogspot.com. As a pro-life libertarian, Paul finds himself at home within the broader conservative movement, and believes in a big tent Republican Party. In May 2016 Paul was elected as Chairman of the 11th Congressional District Republican Committee. Paul resides in western Fairfax County with his wife and children.

Your life will be better if you click one of these

Sunday Memes–Shame on Gavin Newsome and Pam...

July 13, 2025

The Foundation of Democracy

July 11, 2025

Memes of the Day

July 11, 2025

The Case for Insurrection

July 11, 2025

So what is the end state in...

July 9, 2025

Gov. Youngkin’s wife and family members rescued...

July 9, 2025

E Pluribus Unum– a reflection of who...

July 7, 2025

Socialism’s Great Myths – Back Again

July 6, 2025

Biden Makes an Appearance

July 6, 2025

I am a Born Again Christian and...

July 6, 2025

Leave a Comment

Fun Stuff

  • Sunday Memes–Shame on Gavin Newsome and Pam Bondi

  • Sunday Memes–Celebrating our Independence

  • Meme(s) of the Day

  • Sunday Memes–Bombs Away

  • Meme of the Day

Advertisement

Advertisement

Sign Up for Email Alerts


Select list(s):

Check your inbox or spam folder now to confirm your subscription.

Advertisement

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

@2017 Bull Elephant Media LLC.


Back To Top
%d